My! Robot
OK, so I'm not a headline writer ala Dawn Eden but the point is that "I, Robot" is a quite excellent movie and I recommend it highly to any (1) sci-fi fans, (2) Will Smith fans and (3) action movie genre fans.
This is the first movie I can recall where Smith displays a truly wide range of acting skills. I've always respected his ability as a comedic/action guy, but he's pushing the envelope and doing so quite well.
The script respects the viewer, requiring you to fill in a few blanks here and there. It's not a epic intellectual exercise, by any stretch of the imagination, but neither is it a "Chronicles of Riddick."
It's also not a literal remake of Isaac Asimov's classic collection of short stories with the same name. It's been many years since I've read those stories, but the movie made the potential complications of Asimov's "Three Laws of Robotics" come to life in ways my imagination never did.
My favorite movies are those which introduce me to characters I care about, and which (intentionally) make me laugh while still challenging my imagination. "I, Robot" succeeds on every level.
From a sci-fi perspective, almost everything rang true, although I will quibble with the decision to use the term "nanites" (which sounds like a clan from one of the tribes of Israel) in place of the more commonly-seen "nanobots," and I had to wonder if the set for the climactic scene was borrowed from a Star Wars movie. At one point, I channeled "The Terminator" (but never saw the twist coming that changed the whole direction of the plot...if you see the movie, you'll know what I mean).
I left the theater with only one question: just how much did Audi pay for its very prominent product placement?
For my money, "I, Robot" is one of the best movies of the year.
I read your review before I saw the movie, but I forgot you mentioned The Terminator until I reread it again yesterday after I saw the movie. I had a moment when I thought of The Terminator (it was towards the end). And I get what you're saying about Star Wars too. But I really liked the movie.
Posted by: jen at July 19, 2004 12:44 PM**Spoiler Alert -- Don't read if you haven't seen the movie!**
Jen, didn't you think there were a couple of niggling little flaws in the logic of the plot, though? I didn't write about them in the post, because I didn't want to put spoilers into the review. The central computer was just a little too vulnerable for my tastes, and the non-monitored service tunnels a bit too convenient.
But it's still a great summer action flick...I may have to see it again!
Posted by: Eric at July 19, 2004 12:56 PMI went to see I,Robot this weekend expecting to hate it and boy was I in for a shock. While I won't call it the best movie of the year, I wouldn't hesistate to reccomend it to friends and family. There were too many cliches in the movie for my tastes, but that is a personal matter.
****Spoiler alert****
My hands down favorite sequence in this movie is when Will Smith goes to the robot storage area for the first time and the Doctor is giving his voice over on the Ghost's in the Machine. How robot programing will develop on it's own and in one sequence he mentions how the robots will instinctively stand together as opposed to standing apart. While he is saying this the camera is shooting from inside a container, the robots are huddled in a group along the right side of the container, and the light from Smith's flashlight lights the interior of the storage container brilliantly. I got goosebumps watching that scene. It was a classic Proyas moment.

You nailed it! My review parrots yours; instead of writing my own, I should’ve just referred to it. In retrospect, I think I read yours, and forgot. Sorry.
Posted by: Daniel Morris at July 17, 2004 04:51 AM