Hurricane blogging predicament
A couple of recent events have reminded me that while bloggers have a role to play in relaying information in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, there's also an implicit responsibility to do some self-editing and, perhaps, refrain completely from reporting certain things.
For example, my post last night about the Slidell Hurricane Damage Blog was intended to direct folks to a potentially valuable source of information about their families and property in that town. Within minutes after that post went up, the Gazette was getting scores of hits via Technorati from people searching for "Slidell" or "Katrina Slidell" or some variation. Then, people started leaving comments on the post asking for information about their families. Obviously, I don't have access to that information, and I finally had to update the post to ask people not to leave such comments, but instead to visit the Slidell blog.
This made me wonder if I'd even done the right thing in posting that information, because I don't know if the Slidell blog is really proving to be effective. I hope it is, but I just don't know. And I hate to think that I might have raised false hopes in people who are desperate for any news whatsoever.
Then there's this. Deb Thompson over at Write Lightning emailed me this morning that a New Orleans TV station is broadcasting via streaming video. The picture quality is not great, but the audio is fine. This is probably the best source for up-to-date information by folks on the ground because they're not just recycling the same shots and stories like the networks seem to be doing.
However, as I was about to publish this post, the video feed suddenly stopped and it occurred to me that, again, I might not be doing anyone any favors by publishing the URL for the feed. If a bunch of gawkers (like me) end up bringing the station's server to its knees so that the folks who really have a vested interest in the information can't get it, then I've done more harm than good. Given that scenario, I've elected to exclude the identity of the TV station and the URL. (If you have family in New Orleans and want the information, leave a comment along with your email address and I'll send it to you.) It's not as though you can't find that feed yourself, but you might want to ask yourself if your need to know is as great as that of a few hundred thousand others.
Maybe I'm overthinking this issue, but I'd rather be on the safe side of things. In fact, unless I've run across something that really adds to the dialog and reporting related to the hurricane (which won't be much, I'm sure), I'm going to discontinue the related Technorati tags. I don't need the hits that badly.
DO YOU KNOW ANYTHING OF BELAIR SUB. OFF AIRPORT ROAD SLIDELL IT'S AT THE AIRPORT
Posted by: MARY at August 31, 2005 02:27 PMMary, please visit http://slidell.weblogswork.com/ to see if anyone there has the information you seek.
Posted by: Eric at August 31, 2005 02:31 PMEric,
I think you're right to be circumspect about posting anything right now, even stuff that's helpful. Even on this post you've already had a fairly desperate sounding request.
Video footage probably attracts some "legitimate" users, but also gawkers. With the situation in the affected areas seemingly getting worse by the hour, more and more people will probably be trying to get information anyway they can as the realization of just how bad a disaster this is hits home.
I've seen links to relief organizations popping up on some blogs without generating comments such as the ones on your previous post.
It may all be due to your international readership and incredible popularity :)
The winning smile doesn't hurt either I'm sure.
Posted by: Jim at August 31, 2005 03:54 PMCould you please email me the link for the feed? I have been researching information about the Slidell area since Katrina struck. My husband is from New Orleans, we both lived there a while, and my father-in-law and brother-in-law lived in Old Town Slidell. They BOTH got out in time and are safe. However, we are making plans for them to possibly live with us now, and am looking for reliable, realistic information about the extent of the damage.
Thank you very much!
-Trish
Trish, it's on its way!
Posted by: Eric at August 31, 2005 04:00 PMThe winning smile doesn't hurt either I'm sure.
Yeah, everyone's a sucker for a gap-toothed redneck grin. (Look how much Letterman's milked it!)
Posted by: Eric at August 31, 2005 04:01 PMEric,
Good thoughts. I hadn't thought much about the idea of bloggers needing to take care to not add to confusion in an effort to help. Good post, a good reminder to slow down and think about how we can do the most, help the most, with what's at our disposal.
Posted by: Julie at August 31, 2005 05:05 PMI'm for more information instead of less. In the absence of knowledge, people get crazy thoughts. Here is a good story from today: Jennifer Watson saw a link to CNN video of Slidell on the blog I've been working on. She wrote me to express her gratitude -- she's been looking for him since Sunday and now knows he's safe, as a result of the video. Work the hive mind, folks.
Posted by: Brian Oberkirch at August 31, 2005 09:16 PMYeah, I feel kinda noise-ish, too. Heck, I want to be out there with a chainsaw doing something. Clicking with a credit card doesn't feel very...helpful.
Posted by: Scott Chaffin at August 31, 2005 09:28 PMBrian, I'm all for adding to the information. My post was intended to address the noise, of which there is an increasing amount. When you get right down to it, there's not much that a blogger in west Texas can add to the dialog when it comes to specific reports on the conditions in the Gulf Coast. Now, I do think I can play a role by publicizing efforts like yours, just to ensure they get the widest possible exposure, and I've done that...and if you can think of any other ways I can help in that fashion, please don't hesitate to let me know.
Scott, based on what I saw on tonight's news, if you hopped in your truck and headed that way, they'd welcome you with open arms anywhere along the Gulf Coast, especially if you're packing a chainsaw. Sic 'em! (But the credit card thing is muy bueno, too.)
Posted by: Eric at August 31, 2005 09:37 PMYou are so responsible. What you are suggesting here takes blogging ethics to a whole different level. Very admirable...
Posted by: mis_nomer at August 31, 2005 10:01 PMWell, now you're making me blush!
I just think that if we want people to treat bloggers as grownups, we ought to act the part. Sometimes, it really isn't all about us, you know?
Posted by: Eric at August 31, 2005 10:05 PMThey say if you show up on your own, you better be able to self-sustain for a minimum of 7 days. Which, I ain't got a truck big enough to haul that many gas cans.
Posted by: Scott Chaffin at September 1, 2005 12:26 AMYeah, good point...the problem with individual volunteers is when they can't support themselves and become another burden on the "official" relief team.
I figured you had your own tanker truck for The Tiny Bidness. ;-)
Posted by: Eric at September 1, 2005 07:16 AMI'm thinking about going there too. I've done it before (North Dakota, 1997) but I signed on with WorldVision then. If (a big if) I go this time, I'm sure I'd choose to go with a reputable relief organization that was welcoming volunteer involvement.
Maybe when the time comes there will be other bloggers considering the same thing.
Posted by: Jim at September 1, 2005 08:59 AMMaybe we ought to organize something, Jim. I'm pondering logistics (smell the smoke?).
Posted by: Scott Chaffin at September 1, 2005 09:12 AMJim, you're an inspiration to us all. You're also fortunate to be with a church that understands the importance of doing work like that. Not all congregations are willing to do without staff.
Maybe when the time comes there will be other bloggers considering the same thing.
Of course, now you've stopped preaching and started meddling! ;-)
This sounds good in theory, but the organizations are likely to find out that most bloggers can't do anything else! (JUST KIDDING, FOLKS!)
Posted by: Eric at September 1, 2005 09:14 AMScott definitely doesn't fall into the "can't do anything else" category. Anybody who can organize a music festival in Texas in August has got some serious skillz. I'd take him up on that, Jim. He can even work with Yankees, if need be. ;-)
Posted by: Eric at September 1, 2005 09:16 AMThe information coming from the local officials and folks in need in the affected areas is a bit different from the news that comes from "higher ups". No matter what the details might be, there are ongoing needs for medical supplies, generators (especially larger generators), equipment for cleaning and clearing and that sort of thing. And yes! It's very important that anyone going into the areas is aware of just how bad the conditions are. The rescuers don't want to add outsiders to the casualty count. If you aren't trained to work in severe conditions, you could actually end up being a liability. But they can certainly use supplies and equipment. The local people are begging for help, and that includes the mayors and parish leaders. There is also going to be a need very soon for folks with building experience to help get more housing built. Eric, keep spreading the word. If that's all we can do, that's fine if it gets one more piece of equipment in there.
Posted by: Deb Thompson at September 1, 2005 11:09 AMDeb, I didn't mean to imply that any of us should stop passing along potentially useful information. I simply think that not all bloggers have equally valuable voices in this situation and we need to think about whether our posts are designed to attract traffic or to impart something of importance. Sometimes those goals aren't compatible.
Posted by: Eric at September 1, 2005 04:02 PM
Mississippi College will open have a special registration for students affected by Hurricane Katrina. Registration will begin Tuesday, September 6 at 8:00 AM and conclude Wednesday, September 7, at 4:30 PM.
Any questions or comments need to be send to Landon Howell at Mississippi College (lhowell@mc.edu).
Posted by: Landon Howell at August 31, 2005 02:21 PM