How about a little good news?

No, I didn't just save a bunch of money on my car insurance, but I did see something on TV that raised my spirits.

I've never been a big fan of Geraldo Rivera, but I'll give him credit for coming up with some unique and interesting slants on the stories he covers. One of those occurred a couple of hours ago on the Fox News Channel as he reported on the progress of efforts to move people from the Superdome to more hospitable environs.

Geraldo had the camera pan over to a group of people -- I'd estimate they numbered a couple of dozen or so -- sitting calmly in folding chairs in the shade of the Superdome. He identified them as a group of Vietnamese who had come to the 'Dome to ride out the storm. He had observed that during the chaotic scrambling to be the first on the buses to take people away from conditions that had become unliveable by most standards, these folks continued to sit quietly. He spoke with them and they told him that they were content to wait until all the others who were so desperate to leave were able to do so. They didn't want to "get in the way."

OK. Wow. So it can be done. One can make a choice to not let circumstances get the best of one.

I don't want to make too much of this, but it does seem that a couple of conclusions could be logically drawn. First, it's not outside the realm of possibility that some of the Vietnamese had been through worse things than this. I don't mean to minimize the tragedy of the situation, especially since I'm living 800 miles away from the reality, but it does seem to bring a new perspective.

Second, I believe that Geraldo identified the group as being shrimpers, or working in the fishing industry. (My memory's a little vague here, but, anyway...) What do you want to bet that those folks had been working -- and working hard -- from the time they hit American shores, however long ago that was, with little or no governmental assistance? My point? Simply that there's a culture of entitlement that forms when generations of people come to view the government as having the ultimate responsibility for their day-to-day care and feeding. And when government fails to meet expectations -- which, really, is inevitable -- those with that culture have no clue about how to take care of themselves. The Vietnamese families in this story apparently decided that their culture would be one of self-empowerment and self-control. That's a great lesson to take away...and a tale of caution.

I hope we see some follow-up stories on this band of Vietnamese.

Technorati tag:

Comments

Dang.

Your Katrina posts continue to be excellent.

Posted by: Julie at September 3, 2005 07:37 PM

Thanks, Julie. I'm not sure why I'm doing them, to tell the truth. I just don't seem to be able to stop.

Posted by: Eric at September 3, 2005 07:58 PM

As I understand it the Vietnamese population in the deep south originated with boat people in the late 70-80s. So yes, they have experienced worse and yes, they have worked hard to be contributing members of the society that gave them a chance when they were down. It's a great testament to their people and their culture and their endurance - to experience this disaster and still put others before themselves.

Posted by: jen at September 4, 2005 05:53 PM

Jen, I think you're exactly right about the "boat people" background. I just couldn't think of that term when I was writing the post.

Posted by: Eric at September 4, 2005 06:39 PM

Most likely they are shrimpers. There's a huge population of them all along the gulf coast from at least Galveston to Sabine Pass, and I'm sure the same in La.

Of course, today Geraldo was back to his goofy antics, standing in sewage water somewhere in N.O. in hip waders doing a live shot.

Posted by: bryan at September 4, 2005 09:10 PM

You know what they say. It's a dirty job and...well, you know the rest. Geraldo's just the guy to do it.

I'm surprised he was wearing the waders. You'd think he'd be immune to the stuff by now, as much as he's ladeled out in the past. ;-)

Posted by: Eric at September 4, 2005 09:27 PM

I am reading Philip Cuputo's "A Rumor of War" chronicling his experience as a Marine officer during the Vietnam War. Following are a few of his observations about the reaction of the Vietnamese people after a platoon of marines had burned their village to the ground.

“They just stood there, silent and still, showing neither grief nor anger nor fear. Their flat, steady gazes had the same indifference I had seen in the eyes of the woman whose house I had searched in Hoi-Vuc. It was as if they regarded the obliteration of their village as a natural disaster and, accepting it as part of their lot, felt no more toward us than they might feel toward a flood. Such passivity struck me as inhuman. It might have been a stoical mask, concealing deep feelings of sorrow or rage; but if that was the case, their ability to control their emotions was just as inhuman. In this way, my pity for them rapidly turned into contempt. They did not behave the way I expected them to behave; that is, the way Americans would under similar circumstances. Americans would have done something: glared angrily, shaken their fists, wept, run away, demanded compensation. These villagers did nothing, and I despised them for it. Their apparent indifference toward what had happened made me indifferent. Why feel compassion for people who seem to feel nothing for themselves? For I had no conception of the ordeal that constituted their daily existence. Confronted by disease, bad harvests, and above all by the random violence of endless war, they had acquired a capacity to accept what we would have found unacceptable, to suffer what we would have considered insufferable. Their survival demanded this of them. Like the great Annamese Mountains, they endured.”

Posted by: john at September 5, 2005 10:20 AM

...they had acquired a capacity to accept what we would have found unacceptable, to suffer what we would have considered insufferable.

John, that pretty much seems to nail it.

It begs the question of where the line is drawn that separates stoic resignation in the face of unconquerable odds, and apathy that sucks the will to survive and thrive from the soul, leaving only the desire to find someone or some thing to blame. I guess each society and city and individual arrives at that line on their own and it distinguishes the survivors from the perpetual victims.

Posted by: Eric at September 5, 2005 10:35 AM
Post a comment [Take your time...we're in no hurry.]









Remember personal info?